Comparison

    Quoting Software for Contract Manufacturers, Compared

    Five quoting tools, and what each one is best for. They differ most in one thing: where the price comes from. Pick the one that matches how your RFQs arrive.

    By Rehaan Bicha, Rushil Desai, and Neel Shetty, co-founders of Metalinked, which makes Astra · Published · Updated

    Where each tool gets the price
    • 3D CAD geometryPaperless Parts
    • Customer BOMs and live part pricingCalcuQuoteLuminovo
    • Routings inside the ERPDELMIAWorks
    • RFQ documents, cost and supplier dataAstra

    The short answer

    Pick by how you quote

    • You quote machined or fabricated parts from CAD

      Paperless Parts

      Costing starts from the part geometry, next to the ERP you already run.

    • You quote PCBAs from customer BOMs

      CalcuQuoteLuminovo

      Both match parts, pull live distributor pricing and roll up PCB and labor cost.

    • You run, or are choosing, DELMIAWorks

      DELMIAWorks

      Its quoting module turns an approved quote into an order in the same system.

    • RFQs arrive as PDFs and spreadsheets

      Astra

      It drafts the quote from the line items and shows every cost input for your estimator.

    • You quote a few repeat parts

      A spreadsheet

      One estimator and a well-kept sheet is still the right answer at low volume.

    At a glance

    The comparison

    Each vendor's facts come from its own site, read 21 October 2026. Pricing and plans change, so we date them.

    ToolBuilt forHow it prices a quoteIts own pricingTry before buyingERP
    Paperless PartsJob shops and contract manufacturers: CNC, sheet metal, Swiss, additive, rubberFrom CAD geometry, with router and pricing templatesNot publishedFree demo; no trial statedWorks alongside one; names JobBOSS, E2, Epicor, Global Shop, ProShop and others
    CalcuQuoteEMS and PCBA assemblers, plus OEMs and distributorsFrom BOMs, with live distributor pricing, supplier bids, labor, overhead and PCB costTiers named, no figures published; monthly, cancel anytimeFree demo; no trial statedCetec ERP connector; other ERP, MES, CRM and PLM systems by API
    LuminovoEMS providers and electronics OEMsFrom BOMs and PCB files, with live distributor data and a cost model of your factoryNot published; one-time implementation feeNo free trial; a no-commitment proof-of-value phaseConnects to SAP, Microsoft, Epicor, Infor and others; says an ERP is ideal
    DELMIAWorksSmall and mid-sized discrete manufacturers: plastics, stamping, machining, medical, aerospaceFrom routings and cost data inside the ERPNot published; priced by modules, users and locationsNone statedIt is the ERP
    AstraContract manufacturers whose RFQs arrive as PDFs, spreadsheets and emailsFrom the RFQ's line items, checked against current cost and supplier dataNot published; one flat monthly price for the whole companyScoped with our team; guided setup in month oneOptional: read-only, or an export, when your process needs it

    Scroll the table sideways to see every column.

    Tool by tool

    What each one is best for

    Paperless Parts

    Quoting and estimating for job shops

    Best for: Machine and fabrication shops that quote parts from 3D CAD models and want geometry-based costing next to their ERP.

    Watch out for: Its processes are machining and fabrication; PCBA and electronics are not mentioned. Pricing needs a sales conversation.

    Source: paperlessparts.com · pricing · integrations

    CalcuQuote

    EMS and PCBA quoting, now part of Elisa IndustrIQ

    Best for: EMS and PCBA assemblers who quote from customer BOMs and want component pricing and supplier bids in one cost rollup.

    Watch out for: Its own FAQ puts typical onboarding at 30 to 90 days, and no prices are published.

    Source: elisaindustriq.com/calcuquote · pricing

    Luminovo

    Electronics quoting and sourcing

    Best for: EMS providers that want BOM quoting, PCB costing and component sourcing in one electronics-specific platform.

    Watch out for: Electronics only, and it works best with an ERP already in place.

    Source: luminovo.com quoting · integrations

    DELMIAWorks

    Manufacturing ERP with a quoting module

    Best for: Manufacturers running or choosing DELMIAWorks who want an approved quote to become a BOM and sales order in the same system.

    Watch out for: Quoting comes as part of an ERP, not as a standalone tool.

    Source: quoting module · FAQ

    Astra

    RFQ intake to quote draft, by Metalinked

    Best for: Contract manufacturers who want each RFQ turned into a draft quote, with every cost input shown, for an estimator to review and send.

    What it does not do: It does not price parts from CAD geometry. If you quote machined parts from 3D models, a CAD-based tool fits that work.

    It reads incoming RFQs, pulls out the line items, checks current cost and supplier data, and hands your team a quote draft. Your estimator reviews, adjusts and sends; nothing reaches a customer unapproved. It uses your ERP, read-only or from an export, when your process needs it.

    Source: how Astra quotes

    Take this into any demo

    Six questions for the vendor, including us

    The useful questions are the ones where a weak product has to give a vague answer.

    What happens to an RFQ that arrives as a PDF?
    Line items are extracted automatically, and anything ambiguous is flagged rather than guessed.
    Where does your cost data come from?
    Your own history and supplier pricing, with the source shown on each line.
    What do you do when part data is missing?
    It is flagged for review. A tool that silently fills gaps is the one that loses margin.
    Can two estimators produce different quotes?
    Inputs are standardised, and any deviation is visible and attributable.
    What has to change in our ERP?
    Nothing. Read-only integration, or an export if that is easier.
    Who approves before it reaches the customer?
    Your estimator, always. Automation prepares, people decide.

    Be honest with yourself

    Where quoting software will not help

    • If your quotes are genuinely bespoke engineering studies, the research is the work and automation has little to remove.
    • If your cost history is not recorded anywhere, no tool can reconstruct it. Automation surfaces the data you have; it does not create data you never captured.
    • If quotes are slow because of internal approvals rather than preparation, faster preparation will not shorten the cycle.
    • If you quote a small number of repeat parts, a well-maintained spreadsheet is probably still the right answer.

    FAQ

    Questions estimators ask

    Is quoting software worth it below a certain RFQ volume?

    Roughly, if you quote a handful of jobs a week and the same estimator handles all of them, the coordination cost is low and a spreadsheet holds up. The economics change when volume outgrows one person's memory, or when several estimators need to produce consistent numbers.

    Do we have to replace our ERP?

    No, and be wary of anyone who says yes, unless you are choosing an ERP anyway. An ERP is a system of record and it is good at that. Most quoting tools sit beside it and read what already exists. Astra uses your ERP only when your quoting process needs it, read-only or from an export.

    Which tool should an EMS provider look at first?

    If you quote PCBAs from customer BOMs, start with the electronics-specific tools, CalcuQuote and Luminovo, which price components from live distributor data. If your RFQs arrive as mixed documents and you mainly want the retyping gone, compare them with a document-first tool like Astra.

    How is this different from an RFQ portal?

    A portal collects requests. It does not read the BOM, match parts to your cost history, compare supplier pricing, or check margin. Those are the slow steps, and they are the ones worth automating.

    What about quotes we lose on price?

    Automation will not make you cheaper. It shortens turnaround and makes pricing consistent, which mostly wins the deals lost to being late or to a number nobody could justify. If you are losing purely on cost base, this is the wrong lever.

    How long before it is useful?

    It depends on how accessible your part and cost history is. A team with clean exports is quicker than one whose pricing lives in five spreadsheets and an inbox. Any specific number quoted before seeing your data is invented.

    See how Astra drafts a quote from a real RFQ

    Configure an Astra against your own quoting workflow, or talk it through with our team.